Models and criteria for sequencing writing assignments

Models for sequences of writing assignments:

(N.B.: many of these sequence models overlap or are very similar. Several models may be used in crafting a sequence)

  1. Genres of discourse
  2. . This is a traditional organization followed by many college anthologies. The progression commonly runs: personal essay informational essay expository piece comparison and contrast persuasive essay analysis
  3. Aims of discourse
  4. . This sequence begins with fairly simple, unilateral goals to more complex social goals: express inform explain analyze debate persuade
  5. Types of sources
  6. . Beginning with personal experience, this sequence asks writers to use increasingly more sophisticated sources: personal experience single source popular journalistic writing using two sources interviews, field data synthesis of multiple sources scholarly articles/books
  7. Expanding audience
  8. . This sequence assumes that changing the nature of the stipulated audience will govern the complexity of the writing assignments: writing for self writing for classmates writing for college peers writing for general public writing for scholarly discipline
  9. Intellectual independence
  10. . According to this model, students are initially given very restricted assignments, then are gradually asked to assume more critical independence: theme, purpose, audience, sources stipulated purpose, audience, sources stipulated purpose, audience stipulated purpose only stipulated (students choose sources, type of audience, and topic)
  11. Cognitive complexity
  12. . This model looks very similar to models 1, 2 & 5; the tenet is that assignments should pose increasingly more difficult intellectual tasks: summary comparison & contrast synthesis analysis argument persuasion
  13. Thematic ordering.
  14. Some topic-based courses may lend themselves to themes which build on each other and are increasingly complex, e.g.: family units local community national identities global online communities

SAMPLE SEQUENCE USING MODELS 1, 2, 6 (special thanks to Wes Chapman)

Paper 1: personal position on a text; letter to editor of Argus

Paper 2: compare two authors and take a position of your own for classmates

Paper 3: report on local issue (e.g., housing) for local community

Paper 4: persuasive paper (e.g., an advocacy web site)

Paper 5: short research paper analyzing popular phenomenon

Sources: personal experience, 1 reading

Sources: two readings

Sources: 3-4; some assigned; various kinds of sources

Sources: 5-6; none assigned; various kinds, some stipulated.

Sources: 8-10; none assigned; various kinds, some stipulated

Goals: expression; critical reading; summary; quoting; thesis sentence; claims & support

Goals: critical reading; claims & support; thesis; analyzing tenets & arguments; analyzing evidence

Goals: analyzing evidence; summary; quoting; synthesizing main ideas from multiple sources

Goals: summary; quoting; citing sources; creating effective claims with evidence; shaping a logical chain; using powerful language

Goals: analysis; summary; using sources to back claims; crafting a cohesive argument

Prep work: class discussion with focus questions; summarizing (glossing); freewriting & invention; in-class conferences on thesis statements

Prep work: discussion of texts; role-playing; double-entry glossing or group records; online chat; analyzing syllogisms and assumptions

Prep work: how to organize information; evaluating sources; integrating & citing sources; small group discussion; library tutorial

Prep work: whole- and small-group discussion of persuasive readings; resistant reader role; conferences; collaboration?

Prep work: more evaluation of sources; conferences; one-on-one buddy system; small group review

best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video best video